Friday, May 4, 2012

Reviews: Captain America: The First Avenger



                  Captain America: The First Avengers is probably the best film of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. It’s the grandest in scope, the most complete in its storyline, and contains some of the most thrilling action sequences of the whole series. It’s a war movie, superhero film, and old-fashioned adventure story all wrapped up in a surprisingly epic storyline.
                  We start off (following a brief opening in the modern-day arctic) in Norway, 1942, where Nazi Agent Johan Schmidt AKA the Red Skull (Hugo Weaving, channeling Werner Herzog) is searching for the Tesseract: a glowing Cube containing unlimited power (“And the Fuehrer digs for trinkets in the desert…”). Meanwhile, in Brooklyn, we meet 97-pound asthmatic Steve Rogers (Chris Evans) in a movie theater, telling off an obnoxious jerk for jeering at a patriotic newsreel. He takes a beating for his troubles, but is saved by his best friend, Bucky Barnes (Sebastian Stan), who has one night left before he leaves to serve in Europe, which he and Steve spend at a fair showcasing future technologies being developed by Howard Stark (Dominic Cooper, looking very much like a younger John Slattery). Steve, we learn has applied for enlistment at least five times in different cities and been classified 4-F every time. “There are men laying down their lives,” he says. “I’ve got no right to do any less than them.” Taking advantage of an enlistment booth at the fair, he tries again, but this time he catches the eye of Dr. Abraham Erskine (Stanley Tucci), who believes that Steve has exactly the qualities he needs for a special project.
                  Recruited under Col. Chester Phillips (Tommy Lee Jones, effortlessly stealing every scene he’s in) and British agent Peggy Carter (Hayley Atwell), Rogers is chosen to participate in a new super-soldier program; a technique developed by Erskine that supposedly will turn even skinny little Rogers into the peak of human perfection. The technique is a success, but a Nazi agent infiltrates the facility, kills Erskine, and destroys the equipment, leaving Rogers as America’s only super-soldier. With Phillips unable to find much use for a single such solider, Rogers is sidelined into a USO act. Until, that is, he discovers during a tour in Italy that Bucky had been captured, together with a good part of his unit. With Carter and Stark’s help, he conducts a daring raid behind enemy lines to rescue the prisoners, in the process coming face-to-horribly-scarred-face with Schmidt, who by now has split off from the Nazis to form his own cult-like group organization known as HYDRA.
                  Having demonstrated his potential, “Captain America” (named after the character he played in the USO shows) is equipped with a new, bullet-proof circular shield and given command of an elite commando unit tasked with finding and destroying HYDRA installations, while Schmidt perfects his plans for world domination…
                  The above is a very cursory summary: there is a LOT going on here. That doesn’t mean it’s an overstuffed tangle like Iron Man 2, however: it just means that the film covers a lot of story over its running time. We follow Steve Rogers all the way from his recruitment, through basic training, the super-soldier procedure, the USO, his raid on HYDRA, then finally his emergence as Captain America. As such, the film can feel like it’s taking a long time to really get going, though its almost never boring.
                  As the final film before The Avengers there’s a kind of micro-tour of the MCU woven seamlessly into the storyline. We have Howard Stark representing the Iron Man films (and reminding us more than a little of his future offspring), while the super-soldier procedure itself is recognizable as a more perfected version of what Blonsky went through in The Incredible Hulk (a reference to ‘vita rays’ during the procedure, meanwhile, is a nod to Bruce Banner’s unwitting attempt to recreate the procedure). Meanwhile the Red Skull’s weapons and technology are all powered by the Tesseract (or Cosmic Cube as fans call it), which he describes as “The jewel of Odin’s throne room” and which made a brief appearance in Thor. Yggdrasil is referenced at one point and even makes a brief appearance at the climax. These elements are so well woven into the storyline that I honestly didn’t even register most of them until this last viewing.
                  But Captain America isn’t just a preparatory film for The Avengers; it’s its own story, the story of Steve Rogers, a skinny boy from Brooklyn who desperately wanted to serve his country and winds up becoming one of its biggest heroes. It’s a story the film tells very well, particularly considering how much ground it has to cover. Unlike the tangled Iron Man 2 or the multi-world, character, and plotline Thor, Captain America is a very straightforward film for all its epic scope. There is Captain America and there is the Red Skull: the only two super-soldiers in the world. Red Skull wants to conquer/destroy the world, Captain America wants to defend his country/the world. That’s really the extent of the plot at its most basic form, and the film greatly benefits from its focused storyline: an attempt to juggle too much would have been fatal.
                  This is the first film in the series that has too many action scenes to do my usual run-down: there’s Cap’s introductory chase of a HYDRA agent through the streets of Brooklyn, his raid on the HYDRA facility, a montage of he and his men attacking HYDRA plants, and the climactic battle aboard a giant flying wing bound for New York. Those are just the major ones, there are others scattered throughout. This is the most action-packed film of the MCU. The action itself is frenetic, well choreographed, and as exciting as any you’ll ever see. There’s tremendous creativity throughout, in the HYDRA weapons, in the way the fights play out, in Cap’s applications of his powers and, once he gets it, his trademark circular shield, which is a seriously cool weapon for all its simplicity. The climactic confrontation between Cap and Red Skull is, I would say, one of the best, if not the best, villain-hero showdowns in the entire series; it’s only possible rival being the Hulk-Abomination battle. But even that, outsized and brutal as it was, didn’t have the same sense of climax, of two nemeses having their epic final meeting that this one does.
                  The film’s primary strength is its protagonist: Steve Rogers, who is that rarest of cinematic beasts, the genuinely good person. He’s polite, brave, empathetic, noble, a born leader, and almost painfully self-sacrificing. Rogers is exactly the person you would want as your country’s hero, the epitome of everything good about America. He sets out to do his duty and lets nothing stand in the way of his doing it, even if it costs him everything.
                  Likeable as Bruce Banner was, noble and brave as Thor was, and well-intentioned as Tony Stark was, Steve Rogers bests them all in the hero department. He’s quite simply the most heroic superhero yet on screen…possibly ever. I can’t recall a single superhero who makes a comparable sacrifice, in cold blood, that Cap makes here, a move that, far from being a last-minute development or isolated incident, is exactly what we have come to expect of Captain America.
                  Chris Evans really surprised me in this film. I had only seen him previously in the awful Fantastic Four, wherein he was the very worst thing about a very bad movie. Here, though, he couldn’t be more different. He inhabits the role of Cap as though born to play it, coming across as earnest, polite, and good-hearted as you could wish for. Not only that, but his acting is really quite good, measured and moderately reserved, as though he is disciplined enough to hold back his feelings when necessary, but not so much that we can’t see and understand what he is feeling. Cap is our best hero yet, and much of the credit for making him so must go to Evans.
                  He’s well matched in Hugo Weaving, who takes to his roll with much scenery-chewing gusto. He’s the most ‘pure’ villain we’ve had so far: he’s not complex, he doesn’t have a deteriorating character arc, he’s just a crazed Nazi with a red head and a god complex trying to take over the world. And you know what? That’s all he needs to be. Weaving is a delight to watch as he hams it up for all to see, while still maintaining a definite air of menace and cruel genius. He’s fun, but he’s still a very credible threat to our hero. I’d place him just behind Loki as the second-best villain in the MCU.
                  The makeup that creates the Red Skull is surprisingly effective: at first glance it appears rubbery and fake, but once he starts speaking it isn’t long before we grow accustomed to it. It’s certainly a vivid image, his blood red, skull-like visage rising out from the black leather SS Uniform, like some inhuman demon.
                  Hayley Atwell as Peggy Carter gives some surprisingly good support to Evans. Their relationship and inevitable romance progresses gracefully and believably, though for the viewer it’s rather sad to watch as we know that it’s doomed from the start to be cut short. Atwell also does a pretty good job of portraying a strong, tough woman: almost a precursor to Black Widow. She has a number of very good moments, as when she pegs a driver from city-block away, or when she enacts her frustration with Rogers in an impromptu test of his shield’s durability. She’s a likeable, self-possessed character whom we could easily see ending up with Rogers, had things gone differently.                   
                  Sebastian Stan, meanwhile, is likewise a strong supporting character, and his friendship with Steve is portrayed with care and feeling. The two obviously care for each other and feel like they’ve got each other’s backs (literally in a couple of scenes). For all that Bucky doesn’t have a whole lot of screen time, he makes a surprisingly strong impression. He also gets a number of very funny lines (seeing the Red Skull for the first time he nervously asks Steve “You don’t have one of those, do you?”). 
                  Dominic Cooper, as noted, does a good job of both matching the Howard Stark character we met in Iron Man 2 and letting us see just where Tony got his attitude from. I am glad, however, that while Stark is obviously his son’s father, he isn’t the same person: he comes across as more well-adjusted and less neurotic, as though he lacks the personal demons that plague Tony.
                  Stanley Tucci is quietly enlightened and kind as Dr. Erskine, and makes the most of his relatively short role. He and Steve make a believable connecting during their brief time together, and we can see how much Erskine’s death affects Steve. His best moment is a brief speech he gives describing how Hitler came to power, noting “people forget that the first country the Nazi’s invaded was their own.”
                  Tommy Lee Jones, as noted, just oozes charisma as Col. Chester Phillips, effortlessly dominating every scene he’s in and getting some of the very best lines in the film. Jones is an actor cut from a different cloth than most of his co-stars; an older, more rugged generation, and had he been allowed more screen time would probably have dominated the entire film. As it is, he’s merely a welcome presence and another piece of the movie’s quality.
                  Other roles include Toby Jones as the diminutive, amoral Dr. Arnim Zola, Red Skull’s right hand man and chief scientist, who seems constantly out of his depth amid the guns and explosives he himself invented (he even makes this point directly to Red Skull at one point, complaining that “I only make the weapons: I cannot fire them!”). Then there’s the rag-tag band of commandos Captain America assembles (Neal McGonough, Derek Luke, Kenneth Choi, JJ Field, and Bruno Ricci), none of whom, unfortunately, have the time to become actual characters. Samuel L. Jackson, meanwhile, makes another cameo as Nick Fury, this time showcasing a more sympathetic side than he has in the past.
                  Effects wise, the film is typically good: not groundbreaking, but serviceable. The best effect in the movie, oddly enough, is the pre-super-soldier Steve Rogers, who is created by grafting Chris Evan’s head onto a short, skinny frame. The effect is startlingly persuasive, with only a few scenes where it doesn’t quite work, but even these are really only visible if you are looking for them. On the other end of the spectrum, the one effect that doesn’t really work is the fair at the beginning, which looks a little too much like a blue-screen effect (ironically enough, as only yesterday I was praising Thor for so persuasively placing its characters into much more fantastic and strange worlds than a 1942 New York fairground). 
Most of all, the movie is fun. Sheer, unapologetic fun: the closest anyone has come to recapturing the spirit of Raiders of the Lost Ark since…well, Raiders of the Lost Ark. The filmmakers just take the idea of Nazi superweaponry and run with it, giving us laser guns, laser tanks, massive two-turret tanks, helicopter-jet machines, and, most impressive of all, an enormous flying wing that serves as the setting for the climax. The movie knows that a rag-tag band of soldiers running around Europe blowing up Nazi installations while riding motorcycles and outwitting snipers is an almost fail-proof recipe for a good time at the movies.                 
                  At the same time, though, the film doesn’t shy away from harsher realities. There are a surprising number of deaths among the heroes, more so, I believe, than in any of the previous films (let’s see, we’ve had Yinsen, and…uh…). This makes sense, of course, since it is a war movie, even though it’s a comparatively light-hearted, comic-book war movie. Still, there are deaths, and we are allowed to feel the impact of those deaths on our remaining heroes.
In terms of flaws, one of the most notable is that, as noted, the movie feels like it takes too long to get to what we really want to see; Captain America fighting Nazis (HYDRA). While I appreciate the filmmakers for taking their time and trying to craft a coherent and emotionally resonant story, I wish they had found a way to do so without eating up so much running time. In particular, I thought the USO sequence went on much longer than it needed to.
The vast amount of story to cover likewise occasionally overwhelms, making one feel like there is simply too much here for one movie and that it easily could have been split into at least too. It’s easy enough to follow, and as I mentioned it’s an enjoyable ride, but its also more than a little overwhelming.
 I’m not entirely sure how I feel about splitting HYDRA off into its own organization as distinct from the Nazis. While it retains many of the Nazi trappings (storm-troopers, SS style outfits), it spoils a bit of the ‘America vs. Nazis’ fun, and besides it just feels a little weird: were they worried about the Nazi anti-defamation league or something? On the other hand, it allows Red Skull more room to maneuver and become an existential threat without us wondering why the Nazis aren’t using this technology on the front lines.
Another aspect about that decision, the one that makes me feel most reconciled to it is this; whenever superheroes are shown fighting WWII, there’s a somewhat problematic implication that they are the only reason the Allies won, which is a little bit of a snub to the real-life heroes who actually fought the war and gave their lives to stop two of the most evil empires in history. By shifting its focus to HYDRA, the film neatly sidesteps the issue, allowing Cap to save the world without overshadowing the men who actually did.
The biggest problem for me is that Captain America isn’t allowed to evince much patriotic fervor. Steve makes a couple of references to ‘serving my country,’ but he never is given the chance to talk about why he thinks his country is worth serving. He never really gets the chance to say anything about America, or being an American, or what either means to him. In short, Cap just isn’t allowed to be as patriotic as he ought to be. A brief line during the climactic battle goes some way towards rectifying this situation, but it’s not quite enough to remove the sensation that the filmmakers were uncomfortable with the whole idea of a patriotic superhero. It’s not a huge problem, and your mileage will vary on how much it bothers you, but it’s annoying and definitely takes away from the experience.
           On the other hand, Americana is evident throughout the film's design: from the Brooklyn Bridge and Statue of Liberty in the background of New York to the star-spangled costumes of the USO girls, to the Norman Rockwell-style red, white, and blue credits. Along the way, it manages to fit in trips to the movies, fairs demonstrating new and exciting technology, Army life, ginger-haired kids who of course know how to swim, New York taxis, and baseball. On the other hand again, would it really have been that difficult to fit "The Star Spangled Banner" into a Captain America movie, even briefly?
                  But, as you may have gathered, these are pretty minor flaws. Captain America is the best film of the MCU to date; fast-paced, exciting, funny, and creative. It’s got humor, action, romance, superpowers, weird advanced technology, and a deformed Nazi for the villain: what more could you want?

Final rating: 4.5/5. Recommended to pretty much anyone who doesn’t have an aversion to superhero/fantasy films in general.

Memorable quotes:

Recruit: (reading a newspaper) “A lot of guys getting killed over there. Kinda makes you think twice about enlisting, huh?”
Steve Rogers: “Nope.”

Dr. Erskine: “Do you want to kill Nazis?”
Steve: “I don’t want to kill anyone. I don’t like bullies, I don’t care where they’re from.”

Captain America: “I thought you were dead.”
Bucky: “I thought you were smaller.”

(Regarding Steve’s transformation)
Bucky: “What happened to you?”
Steve: “I joined the Army.”

Col. Chester Phillips: “If you have anything to say, now would be a perfect time to keep it to yourself.”

Red Skull: “Captain America! How exciting! I am a great fan of your films!”

(Investigating a tiny piece of the Tesseract)
Howard Stark: “Hard to see what all the fuss is about…”
(The piece explodes, blasting him back and destroying the test chamber)
Howard Stark: “Write that down!”

HYDRA soldier: “I am sorry Herr Schmidt! We fought to the last man!”
Red Skull: “Evidently not.”
(Shoots him)

Red Skull: “What makes you so special?”
Captain America: “Nothing. I’m just a kid from Brooklyn.”
(Red Skull hits him repeatedly)
Captain America: “I could do this all day!”
Red Skull: “Oh, I know you could, but I, unfortunately, am on a tight schedule…”
(Pulls out his gun to shoot him)

HYDRA Soldier: “Cut off one head, two more…”
(Phillips shoots him)
Phillips: “Let’s go find two more!”

(Cap is about to jump onto the flying wing)
Peggy Carter: “Wait!”
(She kisses him)
Peggy: “Go get him!”
(Stunned by the kiss, Cap looks over at Col. Phillips)
Phillips: “I’m not kissing you!”

Red Skull: “I have seen the future, Captain! There are no flags!”
Captain America: “Not my future!”

Reviews: Thor

  
             Thor is probably the most unusual of all the Marvel Cinematic Universe. It’s a curious hybrid: half-superhero movie, half-high-fantasy adventure film. It’s a mixture that could have very easily failed spectacularly, or dissolved into silliness, but incredibly enough it works. Indeed, it almost works a little too well, as the high-fantasy, Shakespearean elements occasionally threaten to completely overwhelm the Earth-bound storyline.
                After a brief opening in New Mexico, the story proper kicks off with an account of the war between the Asgardians, led by Odin Allfather (Sir Anthony Hopkins) and the Frost Giants of Jotunheim, led by Laufey (surprisingly subtle Colm Feore) fought on Earth in centuries past. The Asgardians are victorious, taking the source of the Frost Giant’s power, the Casket of Ancient Winters.
                Flashing forward to the present, Odin prepares to hand over the kingdom to his eldest son, Thor (Chris Hemsworth); a brave, but arrogant and hot-headed warrior. The ceremony is interrupted when a group of Frost Giants attempts to steal back the Casket, only to be eliminated by its guardian, the Destroyer. Thor insists that Asgard should retaliate for the attack, but Odin refuses, not wanting to spark another war. Accompanied by his friends, Sif (Jamie Alexander), Volstagg (Ray Stevenson), Fandral (Joshua Dallas), and Hogun (Tadanobu Asano), as well as his younger, more level-headed brother, Loki (Tom Hiddleston in the film’s stand-out performance), Thor decides to take it upon himself to investigate Jotunheim, resulting in a pitched battle that destroys the truce between the two races.
                For his actions, as well as his arrogant refusal to acknowledge his mistake, Thor is stripped of his power and exiled to Earth, where he lands in New Mexico and is picked up by astrophysicist Jane Foster (Natalie Portman) and her friends, Darcy Lewis (hilarious Kat Dennings) and Dr. Erik Selvig (Stellan Skarsgard). Thor then sets out on a quest to recover his power, represented and contained in the hammer Mjolnir…which is now in the possession of S.H.I.E.L.D., as represented by Agent Coulson (Clark Gregg).
                The movie’s key strengths are the grand, Shakespearean tone of the Asgard plotline and the easy-going humor of the Earth-bound scenes. Yes, I said Shakespearean, and I meant it. The Asgard scenes play like a “Shakespeare’s greatest hits” collection, being all about war, kingship, fatherhood, questions of identity, treachery, and other mighty themes. In its central question of who shall be king, the story makes overt allusions to King Lear in particular, as well as snippets of Othello, Richard III, and Richard II (Loki’s character in particular is basically Prince Edmund with magical powers). Don’t think I’m being overly complimentary: the film doesn’t come within miles of Shakespearean-level writing, but it does at least take clear inspiration from the Bard, which both elevates the tone considerably and serves to make the story feel much more important and interesting than it would have otherwise. This Shakespearean influence (in the deft hand of Shakespeare veteran Kenneth Branaugh) is the key reason the film works as well as it does and prevents it from being merely an exercise in silliness.
                It’s perhaps inevitable, therefore, that the Earth storyline simply isn’t as interesting. The story of Thor’s exile on Earth, while enjoyable, just can’t match the scope and power of the goings on back in Asgard. That said, the Earth scenes are almost never boring, and are held together by a combination of good-natured humor and the strength of Chris Hemsworth’s performance. In particular, the film does a very good job of presenting both Earth from an Asgardian perspective and Thor from a human perspective. Obviously, the initial assumption is that Thor’s just crazy, but the characters quickly take note of odd evidence that seems to corroborate his story, and though they still take a long time to truly believe him, his earnestness and old-fashioned courtesy leads Jane to at least trust him to some extent.
                I especially like how Thor’s reaction to Earth is handled. When Thor arrives on Earth, he doesn’t suddenly turn into a complete idiot and start, say, attacking cars thinking they’re monsters or panicking when someone takes his picture. There’s some definite culture shock, but he’s able to mostly take it in stride once he bothers to try. For instance, there’s a funny scene at a diner where he chows down on a massive breakfast. Finishing his coffee, he calls for another by smashing the cup to the ground. When Jane and the others rebuke him, he’s at first amusedly dismissive, then apologetic upon realizing that he had been rude. This is actually good writing: Thor may be an arrogant hot-head, but he’s also a well-brought up nobleman trained in courtesy, one who has travelled to other worlds before and, as such, would be aware that different cultures have different manners. Realizing he’s made a mistake, he apologizes and takes note of what’s expected.
                Basically, Thor can understand human culture quite readily once he takes the trouble to. His ‘fish-out-of-water’ moments almost all come early in the film, while later he becomes more or less perfectly functional by the simple expedient of being courteous and not messing with things he doesn’t understand. This makes the film markedly more intelligent than most that have similar storylines.
                The main problem with the Earth-bound story is that not a whole lot happens in it until the climax; apart from one rather perfunctory action sequence, it’s entirely made up of occasionally repetitive dialogue scenes as the human characters try to figure Thor out and Thor tries to recover his hammer. They aren’t bad scenes (though, as noted, they sometimes grow repetitive as Selvig repeatedly calls Thor crazy and Jane repeatedly insists they keep an open mind), but after the grandeur of Asgard and the spectacular early battle on Jotunheim, they’re a bit of a letdown.
                One of the rather surprising things about this movie is how very funny it often is, both on Earth and in Asgard. I’ve already noted Thor’s amusing faux pas once he arrives on Earth, but there’s also the charming “Warriors Three” as listed above, who get some great boisterously humorous moments (“Do not mistake my appetite for apathy!”). On Earth, meanwhile, we have Jane’s friend, Darcy; a mildly apathetic, detached snarker who has little interest in science, but seems to have taken the job of assisting Jane (“She was the only applicant”) primarily for her own deadpan amusement. She gets some of the best lines in the film (“I am not dying for six college credits!”), and is one of the more charming comic-relief characters in recent memory. Then there are the running gags of Jane running into Thor with her van (“I swear I’m not doing this on purpose!”), Darcy’s taser, and Thor being knocked out repeatedly upon arriving on Earth. My favorite scene in the film, meanwhile, involves Thor bursting into a pet shop in search of a suitable mount.
                Performance wise, Chris Hemsworth gives a surprisingly strong showing as Thor. He’s very good at being loud and boisterous, as befits the god of thunder, but his best moments are the quieter ones, particularly the scene when Thor comes to the end of himself and believes that the life he knew is lost to him forever. Hemsworth showcases some great skill at alternating between subtlety and haminess, and good judgment at understanding when each is appropriate. That the film works as well as it does is due in large part to the fact that Hemsworth is able to sell Thor as a real character, both in the larger-than-life world of Asgard and on present-day Earth. He’s the link that binds the two stories together, and he manages that difficult task with grace and skill (he also deserves credit for holding his own acting alongside a powerhouse like Sir Anthony Hopkins).
                The best performance in the film, however, is Tom Hiddleston as Loki, who is quite simply the best villain in all the Marvel Cinematic Universe. A lean, inscrutable, soft-spoken bundle of envy, self-loathing, genius, arrogance, and neediness, he is at once alarmingly amoral and oddly sympathetic. We feel for him in his desire to prove himself to his father and his sense of being overshadowed by Thor. “I never wanted the throne,” he tells Thor during their climactic battle. “I just wanted to be your equal!” Loki excels at deceiving not only the other characters, but the audience as well. Up until the very end, we’re never quite sure where he stands: does he want the throne? Does he just want to humiliate Thor? Does he want to kill Odin? He plays his hand so skillfully that neither we nor the other characters can quite get a read on him until the end. Not only that, but when his plot is revealed it turns out to have been set up so skillfully that there actually isn’t anything Thor can do about…at least without making a tremendous sacrifice of his own.
                Loki is a complex, fascinating character. The best part about him is that even in the midst of his schemes he often comes across as so genuine, so emotionally sincere that you can fully believe the people around him would trust him. What’s more, his relationship with Thor is unusually ambiguous: Thor clearly still loves his brother, even after Loki’s treachery is revealed, but Loki’s feelings towards Thor are harder to pin down. On the one hand, he seems to hate him and even tries to kill him, but on the other, he seems to respond in some way to Thor’s overtures of peace and continued affection.
                Hiddleston deserves great credit for his performance; he makes Loki into a character we sympathize with and feel for, even as we are horrified by his actions. I particularly like the way Loki, while he’s soft-spoken and collected (in contrast with the louder, more emotional Thor) most of the time, occasionally slips into more open expressions when he’s honestly upset. It lets us see that, while Loki is manipulative and deceitful most of the time, he is still capable of real, sincere emotions; of loving and being hurt…
                As Odin, Sir Anthony Hopkins is, well, Sir Anthony Hopkins; what more do you need to know? He pretty clearly isn’t using his full talents, but he seems to be having a good time in the role and lends it his natural gravitas. He does best in his confrontations with his sons; particularly in the scene where Loki discovers information Odin had kept from him about himself. Hopkins expertly crafts the image of a father who genuinely loves both his sons, but cannot entrust his kingdom to either. His disappointment, sorrow, and care are effortlessly portrayed and make a strong impression, despite Hopkins’ limited screen time.
                Natalie Portman, unfortunately, doesn’t make much of an impression as Jane Foster. She’s cute and amusingly flustered by Thor, but we never quite believe that Thor would be so taken by her, or that she would have the effect on him that she’s supposed to. Basically, despite a number of entertaining moments, she’s just not very interesting as a character (as a side note, I can’t help mentioning an interview with Portman I read in which she seemed to think playing a female scientist was unusual. Maybe in the 1930s it was, but in 2011...).
                Stellan Skarsgard does better as her mentor, Dr. Erik Selvig. He lends a level of maturity and clear-headedness to the Earth storyline, and Skarsgard does a good job at portraying his obvious affection for Jane while still setting him at odds with her over Thor. His best scene is a male-bonding moment he and Thor share at a bar, where they discuss being at rock bottom over large glasses of beer (leading to a funny moment where they start an impromptu drinking contest).
                Clark Gregg, meanwhile, has his largest role yet as Agent Coulson, giving the character more room to spread out and grow. Here we get to see that Coulson is a very smart, capable man, able to think outside the box, make good judgment calls, and even shrewdly manipulate other characters to his own ends. He’s a good guy, but he plays a mildly antagonistic role here, appropriating all of Jane’s equipment and data (including Darcy’s ipod), in essence rather coldly taking away her life’s work. Coulson is pretty much Thor’s main opponent on Earth, and he shows himself to be more than up to the challenge. He also gets a number of very funny moments, such as when he finds himself face-to-face with the Destroyer. “One of Stark’s?” an agent asks. “I don’t know,” Coulson sighs. “Guy never tells me anything…”
                Other roles generally don’t make too much impression, but are well played enough. I mentioned Kat Dennings as Darcy being one of the funniest elements in the film, but again I’d like to give her a shout out for being comic-relief without becoming too annoying. Ray Stevenson, Joshua Dallas, and Tadanobu Asano as the Warriors Three don’t have a whole lot to do, and are never really as badass as they’re supposed to be, but they are fun enough company and get a number of good moments. Jamie Alexander as Sif fares a little better, but she likewise doesn’t have much to do (and the mythology buff in me has to wonder: was it really that hard to make Sif blond, seeing as that was practically her whole shtick in the myths?). Idris Elba, by contrast, is rather startlingly memorable as Heimdall the watchman, being pretty much the only character who is exactly as I pictured him from the myths: a no-nonsense badass who has zero vulnerability to – or respect for – Loki (the fact that Elba is black demonstrates pretty firmly the maxim that it’s better to get the personality of a character right than the appearance). Colm Feore as Laufey is coldly menacing, but has surprising depth considering his small screen time. Credit should also be given to Feore for giving such a subtle, effective performance while under such heavy makeup and prosthetics. Jeremy Renner, meanwhile, has a very brief cameo as Clint Barton AKA Hawkeye, which he makes the most of with a series of awesomely snarky lines (“You want me to slow him down, or are you gonna send more guys in for him to beat up?”), while Samuel L. Jackson makes his by-now traditional post-credits appearance as Nick Fury.  
                One area in which Thor excels in contrast to the other films of the MCU is in its visuals, which are striking and creative. There’s Asgard with its gleaming palaces, its brightly lit, cavernous halls, and its ocean constantly spilling over into space, and Jotunheim, all ice, snow, and ruins; reminding one of the Mines of Moria from The Lord of the Rings if they had been frozen over. Connecting the two (and Earth) is the bifrost rainbow bridge, which is a simply gorgeous creation, even though we only get to really see inside it once (the more mundane bridge connecting it to Asgard is likewise a beautiful sight, with its ever-changing colors that glow and shift when touched). During the end credits, meanwhile, we get a tour of Yggdrasil, the world tree, here envisioned as a vast nebula spanning the galaxy and connecting the different worlds in a beautiful and poetic visual effect.
                As you can probably tell, the effects are quite good here, though that is pretty much par for the course these days. The Destroyer is a particularly impressive creation; a ten-foot suit of armor that blasts a fiery beam at anything that gets in its way (the beam reminded me most of Godzilla’s atomic ray during the brief period that it was colored orange). The filmmakers also did a good job of integrating the actors into the fantastic, otherworldly environments so that they actually seemed to be inhabiting them, rather than just looking up at matte paintings (for a particularly dramatic example of how this can go wrong, see the live-action Dungeons and Dragons movie…no, on second thought, don’t).
                Of course, for a mythology buff like myself, it was pretty fun noting where the film matched up with the original myths. For the most part, I confess, it’s an ‘in name only’ adaptation: this Thor, Loki, Odin, etc. are clearly not the ones I grew up with (though they’re characters I can appreciate in their own right). There are points of similarity, but they’re clearly different people. On the other hand, an appearance by Sleipner, Odin’s eight-legged steed, delighted me so much when I first saw it that I actually missed a good part of the following dialogue out of excitement. More importantly, the film takes an oft-forgotten aspect of Loki’s character and applies it in a rather startling manner (Incidentally, I’m probably the only one who reacted to a shot of Thor and his companions riding out of Asgard with the thought “I wish they had given him his goat-drawn chariot.”).
                Thor is a rather odd film to review, because while it’s a good movie, and it’s definitely enjoyable to watch, I found it doesn’t really stick with me afterwards. It’s good, but not very memorable, and it has a number of clear flaws. I already mentioned the disconnect between the Asgard scenes and the Earth scenes, but really that’s probably the film’s biggest problem. The effect is rather akin to flipping back-and-forth between a production of King Lear and, say, a showing of Mr. Deeds Goes to Town. It’s not that either is bad, it’s that one is a lot more than the other and you’re rather impatient to get back to it.
                Then there’s the fact that Thor’s redemptive character arc doesn’t quite work as well as it should. There simply isn’t enough of a clear difference between the Thor we meet at the beginning and the Thor we have at the end: he’s a little more polite and humble, but you really have to be observant and to consider the character to spot the points of change. On the one hand, that shows a respect for the audience’s intelligence, and I’m glad they don’t just make Thor a complete asshole like Tony Stark, but on the other it rather damages the effect of the story. Thor’s moment of truth, the moment that’s supposed to reveal him as a changed man, isn’t as effective as it should be, because we don’t quite buy that he wouldn’t have done it at the start of the movie (on the other hand, another moment later in the film in which he has to make a real sacrifice on behalf of people he has no reason to care about shows his changed character much better).
                There are other problems: as noted, the romance between Thor and Jane doesn’t quite work; we never really believe they have a real emotional connection. There are some sweet moments between them, but compared to the great Tony Stark-Pepper Potts relationship, or even the Bruce Banner-Betty Ross romance, it falls pretty flat.
                The attempts to play the ‘this is where ancient myths come from’ card, which is a lame plot development at the best of times, mostly fails since we have the insurmountable problem that the film depicts Thor and Loki growing up after the Asgardians retired from Earth, making their presence in the mythology completely inexplicable (let alone how the myth writers knew Loki would turn evil). Fortunately, the idea isn’t pressed too hard, though it crops up enough and is emphasized enough to be considered a legitimate plot hole.
                Finally, the big central action scene of the film, Thor’s infiltration of S.H.I.E.L.D.’s facility around Mjollnir, is, as noted, pretty perfunctory. It’s well-staged and proficient, but not very exciting or creative (it’s a bad sign when the most thrilling moment in an action sequence is an unseen figure selecting a bow-and-arrow from a weapons rack).
                On the other hand, the other major action sequences, the infiltration of Jotunheim, the battle with the Destroyer, and Thor’s climactic battle with Loki, are much better done, and while they aren’t as creative or well staged as the ones in The Incredible Hulk or Iron Man 2, they have enough moments of inspiration to get along with. The Jotunheim sequence has a number of good conceits, such as the giant monster that shows up mid-way through the battle (and at one point ends up running upside-down beneath the planet’s surface), and serves a good showcase for Thor’s powers. Actually, almost too good a showcase: at times it feels like they’re ticking off Thor’s different moves like the training level of a video game. The climactic battle with Loki, meanwhile, probably packs more emotional punch than any previous climax in the MCU, as Thor tries to avoid fighting Loki, while Loki spits out his complaints about his life at Thor.
                In summary, Thor is ultimately a successful attempt a very unusual type of superhero movie. It combines Shakespearean grandeur and high-fantasy visuals with good-natured humor and the now-familiar world of S.H.I.E.L.D., Iron Man, and the Hulk. It’s true that the balance of these two storylines is uneven, but not fatally so, and the movie is ultimately an enjoyable, thrilling, and emotionally affecting story that is well worth seeing.

                Final Rating: 4/5. Recommended to mythology buffs, fantasy fans, fans of the MCU, those who want to see an interesting story-balancing act, and those who enjoy a really excellent villain.

Memorable Quotes:

(convincing his friends to join him in going to Jotunheim)
Thor: “Who led you into the most glorious battles?”
Hogun: “You did.”
Thor: “And Volstagg, who introduced you to delicacies so succulent you thought you had died and gone to Valhalla?”
Volstagg: “You did.”
Thor: “And who proved wrong all those who scoffed at the idea that a young maiden could be one of the fiercest warriors this kingdom has ever seen?”
Sif: “I did!”
Thor: “…True, but I supported you.”

Thor: “As king of Asgard…”
Odin: “BUT YOU’RE NOT KING! Not yet.”

Thor: “I have no plans to die today!”
Heimdall: “None do.”

Laufey: “You have no idea what you’ll unleash. I do…”

(surrounded by Frost Giants, Thor and his friends are given the chance to retreat)
Frost Giant: (to Thor) “Run back home, little princess.”
Loki: “Damn.”

(after a fight with Jane over the wheel led to them hitting Thor with the van)
Darcy: “I’m pretty sure that was legally your fault.”

(at the hospital, explaining how Thor got there)
Jane: “Darcy tased him…”
Darcy: (proudly) “Yes, I did.”

Loki: “What am I?”
Odin: “You are my son.”
Loki: “What more than that?”

(taking aim at Thor)
Hawkeye: “You better call it, Coulson; cause I’m startin’ to root for this guy.”

Agent Coulson: (to Thor) “You made my men, some of the most highly-trained professionals in the world, look like a bunch of minimum wage mall cops. That’s hurtful.”

(Thor brings a drunken Selvig home)
Jane: “What happened?”
Thor: “We drank, we fought, he made his ancestors proud!”

Thor: “I’ve changed.”
Loki: “So have I.”



               

Thursday, May 3, 2012

Reviews: Iron Man 2

  
              Iron Man 2 is more ambitious, quirkier, and more action-packed than its predecessor. It improves upon the first film in a number of ways, but at the same time fails to measure up to it in a number of important aspects.
                The story takes place about six months after the previous film. Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr.) is now an even bigger celebrity than ever: genius, billionaire CEO, superhero, and one-man-army, he has singlehandedly stabilized the world stage, leading to the longest period of uninterrupted peace in years. Not only that, but he’s stepped up his philanthropic efforts, staging a huge, year-long ‘Stark Expo,’ showcasing the best and brightest technology from around the world. In short, Tony Stark is still a changed man following his conversion in the previous film.
                Changed, not completely different. He may be giving more to the world these days, but he’s still self-centered, irresponsible, and, increasingly, unstable. His social disorders have gotten worse, and he is now prone to reckless, impulsive behavior, such as giving away his entire Modern Art collection, or taking it upon himself to drive in the Circuit de Monaco.
                His excuse for this behavior is that he’s dying: the arch reactor in his chest is slowly poisoning his blood, leaving him with only a few weeks to live, a fact he is studiously keeping from his assistant, Pepper Potts (Gwyneth Paltrow) and his best friend, Col. James “Rhodey” Rhodes (Don Cheadle, ably replacing Terrance Howard).
                He has other problems as well. Not everyone is happy about his taking it upon himself to fly around the world protecting freedom. The Senate, particularly the obnoxious Sen. Stern (Garry Shandling), wants him to hand the Iron Man suit over to the government, while Rhodey thinks he should enroll himself into the armed forces so that he’ll have both some backup and accountability. In addition, rouge nations like Iran and North Korea are working to duplicate his technology, as is his obnoxious business rival, Justin Hammer (hilarious Sam Rockwell), though their prototypes are far from functional (“I’d say these countries are five, ten years away from a working prototype. Hammer Industries, twenty.”).
                Worst of all for him, however, is the fact that someone has duplicated his technology. Ivan Vanko (intimidating Mickey Rourke), a Russian physicist and ex-convict with a grudge against the Stark family, has replicated the arc reactor and uses it to power a pair of electrified whips that put him in Iron Man’s league, a fact he demonstrates very directly at the Monaco race track.
                “If you could make God bleed,” Vanko tells Tony after their battle. “Then people would stop believing in him.” Vanko may have lost their first battle, but he’s made his point: Iron Man isn’t invincible, and his technology isn’t as unique as he thinks it is.
                The incident sends Tony’s life spiraling even further out of control. There is renewed government pressure on him to give his technology to the military, while at the same time his blood-toxicity levels increase dramatically, eventually leading to a drunken brawl at his birthday party that leaves him alone and humiliated as his life draws to a close.
                Meanwhile, Justin Hammer decides that Vanko is just the man he needs to show up Tony Stark. With that in mind, he breaks him out of jail and, as one critic so succinctly put it, “woos him like a bow-tied freshman determined to take the Goth biker-chick to the prom.” Vanko, while clearly disdainful of Hammer (and not without reason), can’t argue that he needs his resources and sets to work on a bigger and more nefarious plan to destroy Tony…
                As you can tell, this is a much less straightforward film than its predecessor; plots and subplots abound, and not all of them pay off. In addition to what I’ve outlined above, there is also Tony’s attempt to come to terms with his troubled relationship with his deceased father (John Slattery), his decision to make Pepper CEO of Stark Industries, and the mysterious, stunningly gorgeous new assistant sent in ‘from legal’ to handle the transition (Scarlett Johansson, surprisingly persuasive in a role most actresses would look ridiculous in).
                One of the most common complaints regarding this film is that it includes too much, a complaint not without merit. Personally, however, I thought the film juggled its numerous subplots with comparative grace, only dropping one or two at the most. Certainly it does much better in this regard than the equally over-stuffed Spider-Man 3 (which, I confess, I enjoyed more than most, but certainly it was a story in need of massive trimming).
                Once again, the movie shines in its dialogue and character-driven scenes, particularly between Pepper and Tony. They’re as much fun as ever, though their relationship has clearly changed at this point. When we first met them, there was a definite divide between them; they were friends, but more importantly he was her boss and she was his employee. Here that line is blurred even before he appoints her CEO; she openly calls his art collection “ours,” noting the time and effort she spent on it, and she generally seems much more willing to call him out and confront him about his behavior. For his part, it soon becomes clear that Tony has by now officially fallen in love with Pepper, but his emotional problems mean that he has no idea how to express this (and his attempts to do so lead to some very funny scenes. “You made an omelet?” “Where do you think I’ve been for the past three hours?”). I’m glad the filmmakers are allowing the characters to grow and develop rather than merely attempting to redo the first movie. This time around their trademark banter is also amusingly mirrored by Justin Hammer and Ivan Vanko, whose scenes together are some of the funniest in the film as Hammer prattles on endlessly while Vanko merely watches with a bemused expression.
                Downey Jr. again carries the film ably; this time showcasing Stark’s deteriorating health and spirits with great feeling and nuance. I particularly liked how Tony was able to go from staring dejectedly in front of mirror one minute to cheekily commandeering a race car the next, letting us see how he is layering on his playboy persona ever more thickly to cover up his own despair at his impending death. He’s also particularly good in the aforementioned scenes where he tries to confess his feelings to Pepper, starting and stopping so many times that he only serves to make her even more concerned about his mental stability. As in the first film, Downey Jr. excels at portraying Stark’s more irresponsible and selfish side while still holding the audience’s sympathies. He lets us see that Tony really is trying to do better, even though his habits and personality issues constantly drag him back downwards. Tony, in short, is a deeply flawed man with good intentions who isn’t entirely sure how to carry those intentions over into practice. He hasn’t lost anything in the transition to a sequel, and is still an interesting and delightful character to watch.
                Paltrow likewise is still a joy to have around, though she’s much more assertive and serious in this film, as she grows increasingly fed up with Tony’s irresponsible, self-destructive behavior (which, as she reminds him constantly, she, as the CEO of his company, has to make amends for). She has a number of very funny scenes with Tony, particularly when he arrives in her office to apologize for the aforementioned birthday party (and to express his feelings for her, though he doesn’t quite manage that) bearing an atonement gift of strawberries. “Do you know,” she says, fuming. “There is only one thing in the world I’m allergic to?” “This is progress,” he responds hopefully. “I knew there was a correlation between you and strawberries.” Pepper is still a strong, self-possessed woman, one you can easily see running a major company and, as Tony seems to realize, not one who would be won over easily. I also appreciate the fact that, despite her being an undeniably strong female character, she is not an action star. She avoids the action wherever possible, and panics and screams when she can’t. It’s good to see that the filmmakers understand that “strong woman” and “badass tough girl” are not the same thing.
                Speaking of which, Scarlett Johansson as Natalie Rushman AKA Natasha Romanoff AKA Black Widow unfortunately doesn’t have a whole lot to do for most of the film. There’s some gesturing towards her being a spoiler in the Tony-Pepper romance, but we never really buy it and the film wisely doesn’t press the issue. Mostly her role involves being mysterious and looking good (two things Johansson pulls of very well, it should be noted), and she doesn’t really come into her own until the climax. Once she does though, it’s well worth the wait. I would particularly like to applaud the fight choreographers for giving her moves that a woman of her size and build actually could conceivably use effectively against larger male opponents, ensuring that our enjoyment of the scene isn’t tempered by overly stressing our suspension of disbelief. Rather than kicking or punching her opponents into submission, Black Widow uses a variety of take-downs, joint-strikes, chokes, and elbows, relying on her speed and maneuverability while striking at her opponent’s weak points. Generally the idea of slim, attractive women beating up larger men is fairly stupid, but here it actually works.
                Don Cheadle makes a very able replacement for Terrance Howard, who, as noted, didn’t make much of an impression in the previous film. Cheadle is more able to match the rapid-fire dialogue, as well as generally coming across as tougher and more military than the friendly-looking Howard. Fittingly, Rhodey has an expanded role this time around, with more emphasis placed both on his friendship with Tony and his own tough-guy credentials (which were mostly theoretical last time). Here Rhodey actually puts on the Iron Man suit (which he only gazed at longingly in the first film) and goes toe-to-toe with Stark. Later, upgraded with new weapon systems, he emerges as a superhero in his own right in the form of War Machine, leading to a spectacular climactic battle where he and Iron Man team up to take on Vanko.
                Mickey Rourke, meanwhile, makes a truly imposing villain. A massive, tattooed Russian, he comes across as the anti-Tony: equally brilliant, but as impoverished and taciturn as Tony is rich and chatty. Rourke deserves especial credit for making Vanko both sympathetic and frightening: he’s not a two-dimensional bad guy out to cause mayhem simply out of self-interest; he’s a bitter, fanatical son taking vengeance on perceived wrongs done to his father. He has a definite humanity to him, keeping a pet cockatoo, which he dotes on. When he speaks, he can be eloquent and philosophical, mirroring Tony’s rare moments of silent focus and introspection, and even shows a sense of humor, particularly in his interactions with Hammer. At the same time, though, he demonstrates an utter disregard for human life, making him a hypocrite of the first order. “You come from a family of thieves and butchers,” he tells Tony at one point, yet he himself sees nothing wrong with murdering innocent people to enact his revenge upon Tony. At the Monaco racetrack, for instance, he casually destroys at least two racecars for no apparent reason before getting Tony in his sights. Vanko is a complex, contradictory character; a villain who is both fascinating and repulsive at the same time.
                Sam Rockwell as Justin Hammer is probably the single funniest element in the movie. Like Tony, he’s an irrepressible chatterbox and billionaire CEO. Unlike Tony, he’s almost completely inept at what he does, relying on his salesmanship and smooth talking to get ahead, rather than his technical expertise. Stark is a genuine genius, Hammer is a self-aggrandizing parasite. Rockwell’s constant stream of dialogue, his repeated attempts to best Tony, and his rather pathetic attempts to schmooze Vanko are consistently hilarious.
                Other rolls are generally reprised from the previous film. Paul Bettany is back as JARVIS, who is, if anything, even snarkier this time around (“Might I say how refreshing it is to see you in a video with your clothes on, sir”). Clark Gregg is back as Agent Coulson, though his role is considerably reduced here, to the point that it’s little more than a cameo (he does get at least one great line though). Samuel L. Jackson as S.H.I.E.L.D. director Nick Fury has his largest role yet, though it still probably comes in at under five minutes (“Do I look at the eye or the patch?” Tony asks upon meeting him). The mechanical arm “Dummy” returns as well, though its role, like Coulson’s is substantially reduced. In contrast, director Jon Favreau as Tony’s bodyguard/driver Happy Hogan has been upgraded from cameo to supporting character and gets some very funny scenes (most of which revolve around his being bested by Black Widow). John Slattery as Howard Stark, appearing in archive footage, gives off a definite Howard Hughes/Walt Disney vibe (I doubt his first name is accidental) and has one particularly touching moment speaking to his son from across the gap of time and death, saying the words he couldn’t say in life.
                The action scenes are definitely improved this time around, with higher stakes and larger scope. The climactic battle is better and more impressive than the previous film’s somewhat routine fight with Iron Monger, and other scenes, such as the fight at the racetrack, likewise show greater creative energy than last time, as though the filmmakers have grown more comfortable with the characters. I already mentioned the excellent Black Widow sequence near the end of the film, but it really is one of the best scenes in the movie, my only complaint being that it could have stood to go on a little longer. The rough brawl between Iron Man and War Machine, meanwhile, is probably the most routine action scene in either film, but packs enough emotional punch to make up for its comparative lack of creativity.
                Thematically, the film is about legacy: what has been left to us by our fathers and what we leave behind in our turn. Vanko inherited bitterness and hatred from his father, in addition to the technology to put his hatred into action. Stark inherited wealth and genius, but also a number of neurosis and character flaws that continue to plague him. Faced with his own death, Stark doesn’t know how to respond and in the process threatens to derail his own legacy (though a throw-away line implies that he intended Iron Man to live on after him as his final gift to the world). The movie, alas, doesn’t realize these ideas as successfully as its predecessor, and the legacy theme doesn’t really pay off effectively, but it adds an interesting layer to the proceedings and lends a little depth to the story. I also appreciated the depiction of Stark’s struggles with his social maladjustment in his relationship with Pepper, trying to struggle past his own psychological issues to make a stab at a normal relationship.
                The biggest problem with the film is that its attempt to take on too much leads to some elements feeling out of place. For instance, a meeting with Nick Fury half-way through the film doesn’t really establish anything that couldn’t have been done otherwise, and welcome as Black Widow is, she doesn’t really contribute much to the actual story of the film. Basically, you can tell that the writers really wanted to include her and Fury in the movie and see the stitches where they inserted them. Both are enjoyable enough that this doesn’t really take much away from the film, but it’s a little distracting.
                More problematic is the way the many, many elements in the film sometimes lead to perfunctory or unsatisfactory resolutions. Stark’s reconciliation with his deceased father, while touching enough, is a little too neat and doesn’t really address what seem to be the central issues of the relationship, requiring the audience to fill in the gaps for themselves. Likewise, another major plotline is dealt with in a massive story contrivance which requires us to swallow quite a bit in a short amount of time.
                Another issue is that it sometimes feels like the filmmakers were trying too hard to bring back as many characters from the first film as possible, whether they had a place in the story or not. For instance, though it leads to some amusing moments, I don’t think we really needed to see Christine Everhart (Leslie Bibb) again. In the same manner, Clark Gregg as Agent Coulson, while always a welcome presence, feels like he’s only here because the filmmakers felt they had to have him to tie the film in with the rest of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. He literally has maybe three short scenes, including the teaser after the credits.
                Other flaws are not so glaring, but drag the film down some. Senator Stern is a ridiculous caricature of the two-faced politician (though he thankfully doesn’t have too much screen-time). Tony’s antics, particularly at his birthday party, occasionally threaten to alienate the audience as well as his friends. Some elements, such as Black Widow’s inexplicably seductive attitude towards Tony in one scene, simply don’t make sense considering what’s been established. We also have to wonder, given Hammer’s gross incompetence, how he managed to get as far as he has in the first place.
                On the whole, though, the film’s strengths are enough that these flaws can be overlooked. We note them, acknowledge them, but ultimately they don’t overly affect our enjoyment of the film. Like I said regarding Black Widow; we know she isn’t really necessary to the story, but we appreciate her presence nonetheless. Basically, the film is enough fun, the actors are charismatic and talented enough, and the action is thrilling enough that we can look past the flaws and just enjoy the ride.
               
Final Rating: 4/5. Pretty much the same recommendations from the first film apply, with the addendum of a willingness to let unnecessary elements slide and the addition of those who appreciate an especially good villain.

Memorable Quotes:

(first line)
Tony: “Oh, it’s good to be back!”

Justin Hammer: “I believe you know Christine Everhart?”
Pepper: “Yes, we’ve met.”
Hammer: “She’s doing a spread on me for Vanity Fair…”
Pepper: “Yes, she did quite a spread on Tony last year…”
Tony: “And she wrote a story too.”

“Natalie Rushman:” “I need to get your impression.”
Tony: “Okay, you have a quiet reserve about you…”
“Rushman:” “I meant your fingerprint.”

(Upon meeting “Natalie Rushman” for the first time)
Tony: “I want one.”
Pepper: “No.”

Vanko: (to Tony) “You come a from a family of thieves and butchers. And now, like all guilty men, you try to rewrite your own history. To forget the lives the Stark family has destroyed.”

(to Vanko)
Justin Hammer: “You and me, we’re a lot alike.”
(Vanko raises an eyebrow)

Nick Fury: “Sir! I’m going to have to ask you to exit the donut!”

(Tony is incoherently trying to confess his feelings to Pepper in her office)
Pepper: “I need you…”
Tony: “I need you too, that’s what…”
Pepper: “To leave.”

Howard Stark: “What is, and always will be, my greatest creation…is you.”

Vanko: (to Tony) “What you and your father did to my family over forty years, I will do to you in forty minutes.”

Tony: “You sound pretty spry for a dead guy.”
Vanko: “You too! Heh heh.”

Iron Man: “You have a big gun, you aren’t the big gun.”
War Machine: “Yeah, it’s called being a badass.”

(reading the assessment Black Widow has written on him)
Tony: “’Mr. Stark displays textbook narcissism…’ agreed.”  

Wednesday, May 2, 2012

Reviews: The Incredible Hulk


         
       The second film of the Marvel Cinematic Universe was The Incredible Hulk: a reboot from Ang Lee’s interesting, but ultimately failed take on the character in 2003. The new film is more action-oriented and closer in spirit to the Incredible Hulk TV show from the 1970s (which, despite its low budget, was probably the most effective take on the character to date, mostly thanks to the superb acting by star Bill Bixby).
                The film starts off with a brief recount of the Hulk’s origins: Dr. Bruce Banner (Edward Norton) is experimenting with ways to insulate people against radiation and is so certain of his findings he tests them on himself, giving himself a massive dose of gamma radiation, which results in his becoming the huge, all-powerful Hulk when his heart-rate goes above a certain level. Discovering that his experiments were actually intended for the military, and that General “Thunderbolt” Ross (William Hurt) considers his whole body government property, Banner has to go on the run while attempting to find a way to cure himself of the Hulk.
                When we catch up with him as the story begins, he’s hiding out in Brazil, working in a bottling plant. This whole opening sequence is essentially structured the same as an episode of the TV show: Banner works a menial job while searching for a cure and exploring various techniques to prevent his transformations, gently woos a local beauty, has a run in with bullies, and eventually hulks-out and has to move on (the movie even plays the show’s beautiful “Loneliest Man” theme at one point). As a fan of the old TV show, I appreciate the efforts to match the feel of the show (the show’s stars, Bill Bixby and Lou Ferrigno, both have cameos; the late Bixby via stock footage and Ferrigno both as the voice of the Hulk and as a security guard who gives Banner a helping hand).
                In this case, however, his Hulk episode is triggered by Ross, who tracks him down and sends in a team to capture him, led by the formidable Emil Blonsky (effective Tim Roth). After his Hulk episode lands him all the way in Guatemala, Banner decides to return to America to seek out the mysterious Mr. Blue, a fellow scientist he has been in contact with who might be able to cure him. Along the way, he returns to his home town and meets up with his lost love, Betty Ross (Liv Tyler), the general’s daughter. Meanwhile, Blonsky and Ross decide to dust off an experimental World War II era super-soldier program in an effort to give Blonsky an edge over the Hulk…
                While The Incredible Hulk is a definite improvement over Lee’s film, and it’s certainly not a bad movie by any stretch, I would still call it the least of all the Marvel Cinematic Universe so far. It fails to craft a clear story arc, makes a number of crucial mistakes, and while it’s ultimately a worthwhile experience, it’s frustratingly apparent how much better it might have been.
                One of the primary missteps, in my opinion, is changing the catalyst for Banner’s transformation into the Hulk from being explicitly anger to simply his heart rate. I can understand the motivation behind the change: the desire to give a scientific rationale for the transformation, but I don’t like it. I think it robs the character of a lot of his meaning and thematic interest. The Hulk is supposed to be an exaggeration of the effects of adrenaline on the human body: our ability to perform starling feats of strength under duress or anger. Removing the specific anger catalyst removes this. Frankly, it’s worth the questionable science to keep the whole “you wouldn’t like me when I’m angry” aspect of the character (that catch phrase shows up, but in a humorously butchered form).
                The thing is, though, that anger still is what actually precedes Banner’s transformations anyway, so the change really doesn’t do anything except dumb down the character’s symbolic power. This means that the damage done to the character is minimal, but it’s still an annoying element that cheapens the film.
                Another major problem is the lack of any real story-arc to the film: the major characters, with one, possibly two, exceptions are pretty much the same people in the same positions at the end of the film as they were in the beginning. Bruce Banner doesn’t grow or discover anything new about himself, nor does he come to accept the Hulk or even acknowledge the Hulk as a part of himself (one scene has Betty speculating on whether the Hulk is actually a separate entity, like he claims, or just an altered version of Bruce, but it ends inconclusively and isn’t brought up again). This lack of any real character arcs or storyline makes the whole experience feel rather shallow: as though the film is intended less as an independent story and more as a character demonstration for the Hulk.
                The final main problem with the film is the character of General Ross, who’s an unreconstructed cliché of the evil, narrow-minded military general who wants to use everything for warfare. Worse, he’s an irresponsible idiot: are we supposed to believe that he would have gotten the go-ahead to launch a full-scale military operation in the middle of a college campus? And shouldn’t he, of all people, know better than to try and subdue the Hulk with machine-guns and small arms fire? In fact, why is he attacking the Hulk at all? Shouldn’t he know that once Bruce Hulks out that the game is over and he should just pull his people out? His goal is to capture Bruce, but he really ought to know by now that he can’t capture the Hulk (shades of the JSDF insisting on attacking Godzilla with tanks and jets: though at least in their case the argument could be made that they have to try something as they’re on the defensive. Ross, by contrast, is attacking the Hulk, which makes his use of such patently unsuitable weaponry that much stupider).
                The worst part is that we can see how, with a little effort, the general could have been made into an interesting character. If they had just exercised a little nuance, maybe by making him more responsive to his daughter’s pleas or more aware of Bruce’s humanity, or even just more concerned about his own troops it would have gone miles to making him a more compelling villain. Heck, if they had only emphasized the fact that he wants to contain and capture a very dangerous fugitive rather than having his whole motivation being to use the Hulk as a weapon, it would have been better.
                Basically, Ross is by far the least effective villain of the series, and the fact that he’s such an integral part of the film really drags it down. Hurt does his best with the role, but isn’t allowed to humanize the character enough to make it worth it.
                To be fair, there is some gesture towards Ross being redeemed at the end, but it’s far too little and too late to affect our opinion of the character. He also gets at least one humanizing moment, where he cries out in fear for his daughter, but it doesn’t help much since the only reason she’s in danger in the first place is due to his own stupidity (after the Hulk has wiped out his entire company, does he really think a single helicopter is going to help things?).
                Fortunately, the film’s other villain, Blonsky, is able to mostly pick up the slack. Tim Roth is an imposing figure; not big, but lean and nasty-looking, particularly after he starts taking the super-soldier serum. Roth does an effective job of conveying Blonsky’s increasing instability and disregard for orders in his eagerness to take on the Hulk. Blonsky’s transformation from brutal, but professional soldier to raging psychopath to full-blown monster is dealt with in broad strokes, but is nevertheless effective, and much credit must be given to Roth for making the transformation credible.
                Other flaws are not as glaring as the two outlined above: Liv Tyler, while she gives a fine performance, isn’t entirely believable as a Professor of Cellular Biology, since she looks far too young to hold such a prestigious position (Jennifer Connelly, who played the same role in the Lee film, was a much more acceptable proposition). She also doesn’t have a whole lot to do: apart from a funny scene where she loses her temper at a cab driver she’s mostly reduced to holding Bruce’s hand in a comforting way or trying to talk the Hulk down. That isn’t to say that she doesn’t do these scenes well, she just doesn’t have a lot of variety to her role.
                Other characters, such as Betty’s would-be-boyfriend, Dr. Samson (Ty Burrell) drop in and out of the film without much impact. Finally, the very last scene of the film doesn’t really make much sense and leaves us with a somewhat sour taste in our mouths…until, that is, we get a pre-credits teaser that washes it out with delightful cameo by Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr., as much fun as ever).
                So, as you can see, this is a very flawed film. However, that’s not to say it’s a bad one, or even that it isn’t a good one. The film’s strengths ultimately outweigh its weaknesses and make for an enjoyable experience.
                First of all, the acting is good across the board. Edward Norton does a fine job selling Banner’s quiet, reclusive nature, his need to pass unnoticed and not let anything get his temper up, but at the same time his strong sense of right and wrong which force him time and time again to put himself into positions that could lead to him becoming the Hulk. There is great care and nuance in his performance, such as the way he constantly scans his surroundings, the way he walks with a slight hunch, and how he generally has very muted expressions, showcasing how he carefully suppresses his emotions. The role of Bruce Banner is one of the most challenging and prestigious among comic book characters, with Bill Bixby’s superb interpretation being the benchmark for all other attempts at the character. Norton rises manfully to the challenge and while he doesn’t quite equal Bixby, I would say he improved upon Eric Banna’s version and it’s certainly an acceptable and skilled interpretation of the character.
                Liv Tyler, as noted, does fairly well in a roll that she doesn’t quite fit. Her best scenes tend to be the quieter ones, such as a moment where Bruce is hiding out at her house for the night and their goodnights stretch long beyond where they needed to, with each reluctant to leave the other, but unable to go any further with each other. She also does well acting against the Hulk itself, coming across a little like Ann Darrow with King Kong (though a scene where the Hulk takes her to a cave in the mountains reminded me more of the Richard Kiel caveman-flick Eegah!). The ‘beauty-and-the-beast’ scenes between the two of them are very well staged and surprisingly touching, with the Hulk effects being particularly good in these scenes. Her best moment, however, is the aforementioned cab-driver scene, which gives us a glimpse of what her and Bruce’s relationship would’ve been like before he became the Hulk (“You know, I know some techniques that could help you control your anger…” “You zip it!”).   
                William Hurt, as noted, does his best with the material he’s given, but he can’t quite rise above it to make Ross any more than a cliché. I discussed Tim Roth’s effective portrayal of Blonsky’s mental deterioration, though it bears repeating that he does a good job of becoming scarier and scarier as the film goes on. My favorite performance, however, is Tim Blake Nelson as the eccentric-though-amoral Dr. Stern, Banner’s mysterious Mr. Blue. He’s so much fun to watch, such a startling contrast to the serious, straight-laced Bruce and Betty (both of whom seem constantly on the verge of slapping him during their scenes together), that it’s actually quite startling when he turns out to not quite be the beneficent character he’s claimed to be…
                Although the film has a number of strong scenes involving character interactions (particularly between Bruce and Betty), it really shines in its action scenes, which are spectacular. There are three major Hulk-outs over the course of the film, and each is unique. The first takes place in a darkened factory, where we only see flashes of the Hulk and the effects of its rage. The second is a full-daylight battle with the army on a college campus. The third is a knock-down-drag-out brawl on the streets of New York City between the Hulk and Blonsky, now transformed into the monstrous Abomination. The actions scenes are expertly staged and choreographed, making full use of the Hulk’s raw power while avoiding the silliness that the previous Hulk film occasionally fell into. Here when the Hulk pounds the ground, punches jeeps, and roars in fury, you really get a sense of just how strong and angry this thing is (one detail which most people probably won’t register is in the first Hulk scene where he effortlessly throws a forklift at Blonsky: for those who don’t know, forklifts are incredibly heavy pieces of machinery, much more so than cars or other similarly-sized vehicles). The climactic battle with Abomination, meanwhile, is quite simply the best monster fight we have had from Hollywood in recent years. It’s brutal, outsized, sprawling, fast-paced, and utterly thrilling from start to finish (though it does end with the unanswered question of what, exactly, is Ross going to do with Abomination now?).
                The effects are, by and large, quite excellent, particularly the one full-transformation we witness, which is surprisingly gruesome as Bruce’s veins bulge green and his bones expand first, followed by his muscles. I like the more upright design for the Hulk, in contrast with the broader, more cartoonish version in the previous film. The Hulk doesn’t necessarily look ‘real’ in that it tricks your eyes, but it at least is solid, heavy, and textured. You have the idea that you could, possibly, touch the thing, and you can practically feel the bulging, rippling muscles under his rough skin. The Abomination, meanwhile, is more reptilian, boney, and slightly top-heavy. I applaud the designers for making it so easy to distinguish between the Hulk and the Abomination, even in long shots, as it makes following the battle much easier.
                Meanwhile, there are a number of creative directorial touches that I liked, particularly how, when the Abomination first appears, we see it from a handheld camera accompanying some soldiers, giving it an almost documentary style and allowing us to feel what it would be like for these poor schmucks as they try to figure out what they’re up against. I also liked the return of the glowing green eyes that signal a transformation, a detail from the TV show.
                Thematically, there isn’t a whole lot to get into here, since, as noted, there isn’t much of a story arc to the film. They more or less eliminated the ‘anger’ theme, more’s the pity, and other than that it’s just a glimpse at the story of a hunted man searching for a cure. Basically, it just feels like a particularly important episode in the tragic life of Dr. Bruce Banner: as if this were a season-ending movie of the TV Show.
                To be fair, though, the characters are interesting enough and what story we do have here (of Banner’s best attempt at a cure and Blonsky’s descent into madness) is told well. It’s a good film, but it’s also a film that really could have been better with just a little more effort.

Final Rating: 3/5. Recommended for fans of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, monster-movie fans, and those who enjoy really good action sequences.
               
Memorable Quotes:

Soldier: “How’re you feelin’ man?”
Blonsky: “Like a monster.”

(in New York)
Betty: “It’s a long way up town. Subway’s probably quickest.”
Bruce: “Hmm, me in a metal tube, underground, with hundreds of people, in the most aggressive city in the world?”
Betty: “You’re right, we’ll get a cab.”

(on the contents of Betty’s purse)
Bruce: “Okay, basically…we can’t use any of this because they can track it.”
Betty: “What about my lip gloss? Can they track my lip gloss?”
Bruce: “No, you can take your lip gloss…”
Betty: “And I need my glasses…”
Bruce: “You can take your glasses…actually, we can use most of it, we just can’t use the credit cards or the phone.”

Bruce (in Portugese): “Don’t make me hungry. You wouldn’t like me when I’m…hungry.” (English) “No, that’s not right…”

Abomination: “Give me a REAL fight!”

Hulk: “HULK SMASH!”

Tony Stark: “Ah, the smell of stale beer and defeat. You know, I hate to say ‘I told you so,’ General, but that super-soldier program was put on ice for a reason.”